The Shortlist – A Personal Perspective, with Stephen Horsford
The Shortlist - A Personal Perspective, with Stephen Horsford
Stephen Horsford joined Damhurst in November 2025 with 15 years’ experience working in search and recruitment for international consultancies, most recently as Senior Manager at Oliver James.
As a Consultant at Damhurst, Stephen works across search, leadership and advisory functions, from executive-level appointments to transformation mandates. Collaborative and solution-focused, Stephen brings integrity, commercial awareness and a dedication to appointing the right people to the right roles.
We spoke to Stephen about why he’s always been fascinated by the insurance sector, his love of learning new skills, and what makes Damhurst such an enjoyable place to work.
Most of us are exposed to insurance through personal lines: home, car, contents. We don’t realise how complex it is, and how embedded in our day-to-day lives. That’s what makes this industry so interesting to me.
Nothing really moves in the financial services sector without insurance. Investment banking and asset management involve high-level, calculated decisions, but they don’t have the same impact on society that insurance does. Decisions around what needs to be insured, how risk is modelled and the balance between premiums and profit – those underpin pretty much everything.
Damhurst has a really unique position in the market. We’re completely impartial and we’re not pushing an agenda; we’re just well positioned to know what good looks like. At a point where our clients might only be focused on one particular hire, or on growth or derisking, we can help them to think about the bigger picture.
Our job is about so much more than finding the right person. We’re not just putting bums on seats but asking, ‘Do you really need them, or is it about changing the way you’re working? What will those bums on seats do when they get there? How many do you need?’ Instead of recruiting, we could be coaching leaders around behaviour, problem-solving and different ways of thinking. That’s where we add value.
It feels good to have clients asking for our advice, rather than just giving us instructions. We can add a depth to our clients’ thinking, shaping the way they approach the problem they’re trying to solve. Yes, it’s great to go to market and find the right people, but it’s more interesting to challenge how our clients think. That’s the really interesting piece.
There’s a real respect for depth of experience and years of service in the insurance industry. There’s no sense of the ‘past-your-sell-by-date’ culture that you get in a lot of other industries. The leaders in this sector have so much knowledge.
Historically, insurance has been considered slow to embrace new technology, but the new generation of talent coming through are used to having technology embedded in how they work. Insurance leaders now need to be more open to innovation, not just to improve efficiency and decision-making, but to attract the right talent.
The best thing about my job is the team I work with. To a person, they’re all great. I’m always learning new things and understanding new ways of working. We all make each other more creative about how we think about problems and what the solutions are. I’ve learnt so much in my first year here.
At Damhurst, everybody wants to help everybody, from the leadership team down to the entry-level associate who joined two weeks ago. There’s no job too big or too small for anyone in the team. James Cooper [Damhurst’s founder and CEO] will be making tea, answering the door, loading the dishwasher. That encourages the right behaviours, both in terms of what we’re trying to achieve and in how we imagine what good looks like on behalf of our clients.
Time management is a constant challenge in my role, but it’s a great problem to have. I might be writing a proposal letter, and then I’ll have a longlist meeting, then I’m meeting a candidate for an interview. There’s always something going on.
Traditional recruitment is very revenue-driven, but you just don’t see that at Damhurst. People genuinely want to do the right thing – they want to help you out. It’s such a nice place to work because of that.
It’s not a culture where you’re trying to get the most money out of a client – it really is about asking ourselves whether we’re doing the best thing: for ourselves as a business, for our colleagues, and for our clients. And that comes back to us in so many ways in terms of the number of people who proactively reach out to us, who want to engage with us and be on our radar and want to involve us in their hiring or wider strategy.
I’ve never worked anywhere like Damhurst. There is a genuine ‘one P&L, one team’ approach. You genuinely see and feel that.
